I Tried a Better Way to Restore Rusty Cast Iron

Video - February 21, 2024

Save 10% on your purchase at Carbon Method using the code SpagCoat

Please note that this video is a paid advertisement and I will receive a small commission if you purchase something from Carbon Method using my code or link. I truly appreciate your support.

You may already know Carbon Method for their rust preventative I showed off in this video and the subsequent testing I did in this video. They have since released a new product for rust removal, the Carbon Coating Prep Kit that contains three abrasive pads and their Reconditioning Oil. Using their kit you can remove rust faster, easier, and more effectively that with traditional abrasive or chemical techniques. When you’re done, the surface is prepped and ready for the rust preventing Carbon Coat. Get your kit here and say bye bye to rust! 

The Carbon Method Reconditioning System

The system includes Reconditioning Oil and three abrasive pads:

  • Maroon: 320–400 grit
  • Gray: 600–800 grit
  • White: 1,200–1,500 grit

The goal isn’t just to remove rust. The three pads refine the surface in stages, leaving the cast iron smooth enough for Carbon Coat. The smoother the surface, the better the protective coating can do its job.

The Reconditioning Oil works as both a lubricant and a rust softener. Carbon Method says it softens red and black iron oxide, helping the abrasive pads remove stains and rust faster than they would with a basic lubricant such as WD-40. The oil also stays under the pad fairly well, which cuts down on splatter.

Assessing the Rust

The drill-press table looked worse several months earlier. Normal use had already worn away some of the light surface rust, but the table still had stains and scattered rust spots. The worst areas were on the chuck and the post above the table-support collar. Those surfaces aren’t flat, so they would need to be cleaned by hand rather than with a sander. None of the rust had caused serious pitting, so this was a good candidate for an abrasive cleaning process.

Chemical Versus Mechanical Rust Removal

There are two common ways to remove rust from tools. Chemical rust removers convert active red iron oxide into stable black iron oxide. This stops the active rust, but it can leave dark marks behind. The marks don’t hurt anything, but they may not give you the clean appearance you want.

Mechanical rust removal uses sandpaper or abrasive pads to scratch away the rust. Sandpaper can leave deep, uneven scratches, so nonwoven abrasive pads tend to work better on cast-iron tool surfaces. The Carbon Method system combines elements of both approaches. The pads remove the rust mechanically, while the Reconditioning Oil helps soften the oxidation and lubricate the surface.

Removing the Rust

I started with the maroon pad, which is the coarsest of the three. The pads can be attached to a five- or six-inch random-orbit sander. You can leave the pad square, but trimming the corners keeps the excess material out of the way.

I applied the Reconditioning Oil across the table, using a little extra on the worst areas. After spreading it around, I let it sit for a few minutes. When sanding, there’s no need to bear down on the tool. Light pressure lets the abrasive pad do the work and reduces the chance of leaving an uneven scratch pattern. If the surface has heavy rust, you may need to repeat the first step with the maroon pad. My table wasn’t too far gone, so one pass took care of most of the staining. 

I cleaned the chuck and post by hand, working the oil and abrasive pad around each surface. After the maroon pad, I moved through the gray and white pads. Each step refined the scratch pattern and left the cast iron smoother.

Cleaning the Surface

Once the abrading was finished, I cleaned the table with mineral spirits and blue shop towels. The surface needs to be completely clean before applying the protective coating. I continued wiping it with fresh towels until they came away clean. At this point, the cast iron looked nearly new.

Applying Carbon Coat

The protective process starts with Carbon Method’s cleanser, which removes any residue left on the metal. After cleaning the surface, I applied several layers of Carbon Coat according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Carbon Coat provides the main rust protection. Once those coats were in place, I finished the surface with Carbon Glide.

Carbon Glide works much like a wax layer. It adds protection, keeps the cast iron slick, and serves as the regular maintenance product for treated surfaces. Applying it from time to time cleans up the surface and restores that slick feel.

The Final Result

The table cleaned up well, but the biggest improvement was on the chuck and post. Both areas had visible rust before the treatment and looked much better when I was done. After living in Arizona and Denver, rust wasn’t something I had much experience dealing with. Missouri has changed that. This process removed the existing rust, cleaned up the stained cast iron, and gave the drill press some protection against the humidity.

I’ll continue watching the surface and report back if anything changes, but so far, it looks nearly new.

TranscriptSo, it’s been about a year since we’ve been here in Missouri, in a higher-humidity environment, and the only cast-iron surface that has yet to be treated to prevent rust is my drill press. Now, I held off because I heard that Carbon Method was going to be coming out with a reconditioning product that we could use before putting on their Carbon Coat. Finally, they have that product, and that’s what I’m going to use here on the drill press to kind of rehab the surface, get it looking new, and then, of course, get it protected with Carbon Coat. So let me show you the stuff they came out with, cuz it’s pretty cool. Carbon Method wanted to come up with a better way to condition the surface and prep it for Carbon Coat. If the surface is super smooth, Carbon Coat just works better, so that’s really what the system is all about. They also wanted to develop an oil that works better than the classic oils we use to remove rust. It cuts through the material and dissolves the rust faster, while also helping contain the oil under the pad so you don’t get as much splatter, which is really nice. So let’s take a look. The system is fairly simple. It consists, of course, of the Reconditioning Oil, and then they have three abrasive pads. The coarsest one is 320 to 400 grit, the one in the middle is 600 to 800 grit, and the white is 1,200 to 1,500 grit. So let’s take this over to the drill press and start doing the dirty work. Now, this surface looked a lot worse months ago, but as we used it and wood rubbed against the surface, that surface rust kind of went away. But you can see we still have some significant staining here that we’re going to want to take care of. We also have more significant rust in a few other spots that aren’t flat. We’ve got one spot here on the chuck that is particularly bad, so we may not be able to get that perfect, but we’re definitely going to use the system to clean up that rust. On the post here, right above that little collar piece, we’ve got a lot of rust hanging out, so hopefully we’ll be able to clean that up too. All right, we’ll start with the maroon pad, the coarsest one. What you’re going to want to do is put that on a random-orbit sander of your choice. A five- or six-inch sander will work just fine. You can keep the pads square. I would cut off the excess, certainly, like that. You don’t have to round it, but I don’t know, I think it looks better to dog-ear it. Something like that, and now we’re ready. All right, so I’m going to take some of this Reconditioning Oil and apply it to the surface. Especially in the areas where there is heavier rust, you want to get in there pretty good and let it sit for a few minutes. I’m also going to hit the chuck and the post. It’s got kind of a citrus smell. I’ve got to say, it smells quite pleasant. I’m just going to dab this stuff around to make sure it’s spread out a little bit. Honestly, I probably could have used less, now that I’m spreading it around. All right, so here we go. I’m not going to apply a lot of pressure. I’m going to let the pad do the work and see what happens. Traditionally, there are two ways to remove rust from our tools. One is chemically. This usually involves using a commercial product that converts the active red iron oxide into inactive black iron oxide. The end result is no active rust, but you’re typically left with dark rust tattoos. They’re harmless, but they can bother the Type A among us. The second option is mechanical. By using abrasive pads or sandpaper and some kind of lubricant, we can essentially scratch away the rust. Sandpaper tends to leave pretty heavy scratches, so abrasive pads are preferred. But the quality of the pad can make a big difference, as can the type of lubricant you use. Right now, we’re just going to take off the schmutz. I guess if we had some heavy rust, we could repeat this process with the maroon pad. But this wasn’t too far gone, so I don’t think we really need to. We’ll also get the chuck and the post. It is a long, smooth shaft. Now we move on to the gray pad. What Carbon Method set out to do is improve this process all around, using high-quality abrasive pads and their special Reconditioning Oil. The oil bridges the gap between chemical and mechanical removal. We still use it as a lubricant, along with the three abrasive pads, but the oil is also formulated to soften the red and black iron oxide, making rust removal faster and more efficient. They say it will remove deeper stains better than lubricants like WD-40 or any other regular oil, and it does it two to three times faster. All right, now that the abrading is done, use a little bit of mineral spirits on some blue shop towels to clean up the surface. We’re really going for clean here. We’ll redo this as many times as it takes for us to have a clean rag. It’s getting pretty clean now. The cast iron is looking pretty pristine at this point, and the next step is to apply the Carbon Coat. I have a video on how to do this from almost a year ago at this point, if you want to see that entire process. But we’ve got a couple of different products. We have the cleanser, which we’re going to use to clean the surface. Then we’re going to apply the Carbon Coat in multiple coats and finish it off with Carbon Glide. All right, so once you have all the coats of Carbon Coat on there, you can hit it with a little bit of the stuff they call Carbon Glide. Think of this kind of like the wax layer on top. It’s an extra layer of protection that helps the surface stay nice and slick. It’s also how you maintain these surfaces. Use this material to clean it up, give it a nice, freshened-up look, and keep the surface nice and slick. That’s really about it. Overall, this worked great, especially where I had some serious rust on the chuck and the post. Both of those turned out really good. I actually haven’t had a lot of experience with rust. Coming from Arizona and Denver, I don’t have a ton of experience with it. I would love to hear from you guys. If you get a chance to try out these products, let me know how they compare. This certainly worked really well. The surface looks almost pristine, and I think this is going to be rust-free for as long as I’m using it. So, yeah, I’ll always report back on this stuff as things develop, but it’s looking pretty good so far.

Advertisers